A Quest for Answers to Questions that Bother(ed) Me the Most

By Anoop Dixith

Back to Anoop's Homepage

Excluding a rare parrot who asked the question - "What color?" thus becoming the first and only non-human animal to have ever asked a question, there are no species other than us in the known evolutionary map that is capable of 'asking questions'. Puzzlingly, research on apes that underwent extensive language training program showed that they successfully learned to answer quite complex questions and requests (including question words "who", "what", "where"). However, so far they have failed to learn how to ask questions themselves.

quiz

That seemingly related trivia aside, a handful of questions have bothered me all through my life. Many have been answered over the course of my life, but a bunch still seem to evade answers that trigger neural gratification! This page lists all questions that bother(ed) me! The answers highlighted for some questions implicitly embrace the gigantic caveat that humans are far away from accomplishing "Basicism" (which is to keep asking why to any answer until there's no answer, and the depth of that why is the "Basicism Index" of that question) to an extreme level and seem to be satisfied by two to three levels of "Why"s.

To give an example of Basicism that I am talking about, let's consider a simple question - Why are (most) leaves green in color? The vast majority of us are satisfied by the Level-1 answer - "because leaves contain the pigment Chlorophyll." Inquisitive people, however, would ask, "So? Why is Chlorophyll green?". The answer to that would be that Chlorophyll is green in color because it absorbs light most efficiently in the blue and red regions of the electromagnetic spectrum, while reflecting or transmitting green light. And the asker would say, "Duh, that's obvious, but why does that happen?". Elaborating, chlorophyll molecules absorb light's blue and red wavelengths because they have the most energy. The green wavelengths of light have less energy, so they are not absorbed and are instead reflected. This is why leaves appear green, and also marks the end of Level-2 answer.

However, ultra-curious people descend (actually, intellectually ascend) one step down and ask why Chlorophyll absorbs red and blue but reflects green. So a Level-3 answer would look like this: 'The green color of Chlorophyll arises from its molecular structure. Chlorophyll molecules comprise a complex ring structure known as a porphyrin ring, which contains a magnesium ion at its center. This porphyrin ring absorbs light energy and undergoes a process called excitation, where electrons within the molecule are energized. The absorption spectrum of chlorophyll molecules peaks in the blue (around 430-450 nanometers) and red (around 640-680 nanometers) regions of the spectrum, while reflecting or transmitting light in the green region (around 500-550 nanometers), where it doesn't go through excitation. This reflected or transmitted green light is what we perceive as the green color of leaves.'

At this point, we are already at a place where we might need to look into Biology (and Physics) textbooks or reference material. However, one level down would take you to your next PhD research - "Why does the Chlorophyll molecular structure absorb red and blue but reflect green?". While the answer to this in a line is "Selective Absorption" (a phenomenon where molecules absorb and reflect different wavelengths because different molecules have different energy levels for their electrons, and these energy levels determine which wavelengths of light can be absorbed), 'what exact structure of Chlorophyll molecule dictate what exact wavelengths and why' would probably be a year-long research project. As you see, at Level-5 and beyond, there's probably no good answer. The good thing is that it is not needed for everyday life, though more of my neurons would have gotten excited if we knew the answer.

To take the side of Physics or Philosophy, though, physicists and philosophers put a disclaimer in general whenever they try to answer fundamental questions: "Physics/Philosophy can't answer all Whys." But again, that's just a wise answer. Ah, it reminds me of "House and Wise" quiz questions that focus on deductible quiz question by thinking How and Why! Also reminds of 11 Questions that Don't Need to be Answered!.

question

quiz

quiz

quiz

quiz

quiz

quiz

quiz

quiz